Proximity to Public and Human Services
The ability to effectively access public and human services when they are needed is essential for population health and well-being and for functioning communities. Public services like post offices are part of the everyday fabric of our society. We rely on other public services, like fire, police, and ambulances, to be available to us in emergencies. Meanwhile, many of the region’s residents, particularly those with low-incomes, rely on human services to meet their basic needs on a daily basis.
Geographic proximity is only one component of access to public and human services, but it is the only component that we can effectively map. (Other factors include levels of service availability, cultural appropriateness of the services, hours of operation, and eligibility criteria.) In the case of public safety and emergency services, proximity can also affect response times, which can significantly impact the services’ effectiveness. Living or working in close proximity to services that residents use regularly can also promote walking, biking, and transit use, which improves health and reduces vehicle trips.
This map series includes maps showing (a) proximity to public services such as police, fire, hospitals, government agencies, and post offices; (b) proximity to human services such as housing services and services for seniors, persons with disabilities, and youth; (c) a composite heatmap that combines proximity to both public and human services; and (d) a version of the composite map that shows proximity by neighborhood.
What the Maps Tell Us: Initial Findings
The Proximity to Public and Human Services Composite map indicates that proximity to public and human services tends to be highest in neighborhoods close to downtown Portland and in other close-in cities like Lake Oswego and Vancouver.
The Atlas mapping tool can be used to assign a proximity score to every neighborhood in the region based on the average proximity of every block in the neighborhood to public and human services. A score of “5” indicates proximities within ¼ mile, while a score of “1” or below indicates proximities greater than 1 mile. The ten neighborhoods across the region with the highest proximity to human and public services are:
Neighborhood |
Location |
Proximity to Public Services |
Proximity to Human and Social Services |
---|---|---|---|
Portland |
5.00 |
5.00 |
|
Hough |
Vancouver |
4.51 |
4.80 |
Evergreen |
Lake Oswego |
4.55 |
4.61 |
Downtown |
Portland |
4.37 |
4.66 |
Grant Park/Hollywood |
Portland |
3.93 |
5.00 |
Arnada |
Vancouver |
3.79 |
5.00 |
Waluga |
Lake Oswego |
3.83 |
4.92 |
King |
Portland |
3.94 |
4.56 |
Old Town/Chinatown |
Portland |
4.17 |
4.34 |
Rose City Park |
Portland |
3.95 |
4.58 |
While proximity to public services such as post offices is likely correlated with population densities, commercial zoning, and levels of urbanization, one would expect proximity to public services such as Department of Human Services offices, and proximity to most human and social services to be related to the locations of the populations most likely to use those services. In general, we would expect populations in poverty to be the most likely clients of these services. But an examination of the top ten list above suggests little relationship between the locations of populations in poverty and the locations of services. Certainly some of these neighborhoods, such as King and downtown Portland, have high percentages of populations in poverty, but many of these neighborhoods, such as Evergreen and Waluga, are not high poverty neighborhoods. The fact that they have such high proximity to public, human, and social services is an interesting phenomenon that would be worth further exploration.
A similar pattern exists even when looking at the ten neighborhoods with the highest proximity to just human and social services:
Neighborhood |
Location |
Proximity to Human and Social Services |
---|---|---|
Hazelwood/Mill Park |
Portland |
5.00 |
Grant Park/Hollywood |
Portland |
5.00 |
Arnada |
Vancouver |
5.00 |
Hollywood |
Portland |
5.00 |
Multnomah County Unclaimed #6 (west of the Hollywood District) |
Portland |
5.00 |
Forest Park/Northwest District |
Portland |
5.00 |
Goose Hollow |
Portland |
4.94 |
Shumway |
Vancouver |
4.93 |
Waluga |
Lake Oswego |
4.92 |
Vernon |
Portland |
4.87 |
Some of these neighborhoods have high levels of poverty, but many do not. The list suggests that some neighborhoods may have high proximity to human and social services because of their central location (e.g. Goose Hollow), proximity to transit (e.g. Hollywood), or because they were once high poverty neighborhoods that have undergone subsequent demographic changes (e.g. Northwest District).
The flip side of this analysis would be to look at how the highest poverty areas in the region fare in terms of proximity to public, human, and social services. Data on neighborhood poverty levels is only available by census tract. The ten census tracts with the highest poverty rates in the region are listed below. While some of the census tracts on this list have good access to services, quite a few of them, such as those highlighted in yellow, have extremely low proximity to public, human, and social services.
Census Tract |
Location |
Proximity to Public Services |
Proximity to Human and Social Services |
---|---|---|---|
41051010600 |
Downtown Portland |
4.48 |
4.50 |
41051003301 |
Northeast Portland |
4.18 |
4.70 |
53011042700 |
Vancouver |
2.40 |
3.86 |
53011041600 |
Vancouver |
3.55 |
4.18 |
41051009606 |
Gresham |
4.07 |
4.10 |
41051003401 |
Northeast Portland |
3.59 |
4.99 |
53011041005 |
Vancouver |
0.68 |
0.80 |
41067033200 |
Forest Grove |
1.43 |
2.12 |
53011041111 |
Vancouver |
3.24 |
3.50 |
41051009301 |
Outer East Portland |
1.44 |
3.73 |
The Atlas mapping tool can be used for this type of analysis to help inform decisions about where to site public, human, and social services, as well as to identify areas that are already rich in services and therefore offer better access to opportunity for low-income residents.
About the Maps
Proximity to Public Services
This map displays proximity to various public services compiled from point data in the Metro RLIS dataset for city halls, fire station, and hospitals. This was supplemented by a list of services classified via NAICS codes (North American Industry Classification System) as courts, police protection, fire protection, government executive offices, and postal service
Data Source: ESRI Business Analyst (2010); Metro RLIS (2012)
Proximity to Human and Social Services
This map displays proximity to various human and social services defined via NAICS codes (North American Industry Classification System) as individual and family services, child and youth services, services for seniors and persons with disabilities, temporary shelters, and other community housing services. These data do not fully capture all of the human and social services in the region due to limitations in the availability of comprehensive, up-to-date, address-level data on these services.
Data Source: ESRI Business Analyst (2010)
Proximity to Public and Human Services Composite Heatmap
This map combines the proximity scores from the Proximity to Public Services and the Proximity to Human Services maps to create a composite heatmap.
Data Source: ESRI Business Analyst (2010); Metro RLIS (2012)
Proximity to Public and Human Services Composite Neighborhood Map
This map uses the same underlying data as the Proximity to Public and Human Services Heatmap, but instead of showing the data as a heatmap it aggregates the data by neighborhood. The darker the neighborhood, the higher its proximity score.
Data Source: ESRI Business Analyst (2010); Metro RLIS (2012)
*Some neighborhood boundaries overlap. The Atlas refers to the areas within the overlapping boundaries by the names of both neighborhoods.
This document was downloaded from the Map Series library of the Coalition for a Livable Future’s Regional Equity Atlas 2.0 website. The Regional Equity Atlas is a research and education project to promote widespread opportunity for a stronger, healthier, and more sustainable Portland-Vancouver metropolitan region. For more information, visit www.equityatlas.org. |